Using Psychology to Create More Engaging Marketing Content

Unlocking the Brain’s Secrets to Boost Engagement

Have you ever wondered why some marketing content goes viral while other pieces fall flat? The secret often lies in understanding and leveraging psychology. Marketing expert Stephanie Scheller shares actionable insights on how to craft content that not only grabs attention but also sparks meaningful engagement.

By working with how people think, feel, and respond, you can create content that resonates on a deeper level. Let’s dive into how psychology can elevate your marketing strategy.

The Power of Storytelling in Marketing

Storytelling is one of the most effective tools for engaging your audience. As Stephanie explains, storytelling taps into both the logical and emotional sides of the brain. This dual engagement increases the likelihood of your audience paying attention and remembering your message.

Why Stories Work

  • Memory: Stories help people retain information better.
  • Trust: Great storytelling releases oxytocin in the brain, fostering trust and empathy.
  • Emotional Value: Stories create a connection by sparking emotions like joy, curiosity, or nostalgia.

Stephanie highlights an example: “Taylor Swift’s Eras Tour generated $5 billion in economic impact by selling a three-hour emotional experience. That’s the power of storytelling.”

Simple Stories Work Too

You don’t need a grand production to tell a story. Even a quick anecdote, like sharing a recent win or lesson, can have a big impact. For example, you could start with: “Let me tell you how I learned to increase my conversion rates in one week.” This format feels personal and relatable, making it easier for your audience to engage.

Emotion Drives Engagement

People remember how your content made them feel more than the words themselves. Stephanie emphasizes this with a simple but powerful question her team asks for every piece of content they create:

What emotion do we want this content to spark?

Example:

The tagline “Ready for an event that gets you?” was designed to spark specific emotions:

  • Recognition: Making the audience feel seen and understood.
  • Curiosity: Encouraging them to learn more.
  • Dissatisfaction: Highlighting how previous events may not have met their expectations.

This emotional approach creates a deeper connection with the right audience, making them more likely to engage.

Building Trust Through Social Proof

Social proof is another powerful psychological tool. It leverages the brain’s herd mentality—the inherent belief that safety lies in numbers. If others trust or use a product, new customers are more likely to follow suit.

Tips for Using Social Proof

  • Testimonials: Include one-liner testimonials throughout your website.
  • Case Studies: Share real-life success stories.
  • Subtle Integration: Instead of a single testimonials page, sprinkle social proof across all pages to make it feel natural and authentic.

Stephanie shares how Grow Disrupt integrates testimonials: “We don’t have a dedicated testimonials page, but we weave social proof throughout every page of the website. People often mention they saw a line that resonated without realizing it was a testimonial.”

Keeping It Simple

In today’s noisy world, simplicity is key. Overloading your audience with information can backfire, making your message harder to absorb.

Focus on Clarity

  • One Key Message: Stick to a single main point per piece of content.
  • Brevity: Use as few words and images as possible to communicate your idea.

Stephanie notes, “The simpler your content, the easier it is for the brain to engage. Complexity creates resistance, while clarity invites attention.”

The Principle of Reciprocity

Reciprocity is a psychological concept that drives engagement. When you offer something of value, whether it’s information, entertainment, or emotion, people naturally want to give back by engaging with your content.

Examples of Reciprocity in Action

  • Emotion: Content that makes people feel inspired, capable, or entertained.
  • Education: Sharing insights that make your audience feel smarter or more informed.

“When you spark emotion in your audience, you make it easy for them to respond,” Stephanie explains. “They feel a connection and want to reciprocate, whether that’s by liking, commenting, or sharing.”

Putting Psychology into Practice

  1. Incorporate Storytelling: Share relatable anecdotes or lessons learned.
  2. Spark Specific Emotions: Identify the feelings you want to evoke with your content.
  3. Leverage Social Proof: Highlight testimonials, reviews, or success stories naturally.
  4. Simplify Your Message: Strip away unnecessary details to make your point clear.
  5. Focus on Value: Use emotion to enrich your audience’s experience and build reciprocity.

Closing Thoughts

Great marketing content isn’t just about information—it’s about connection. By understanding how the brain works, you can create content that not only grabs attention but also fosters trust, engagement, and action.

Start incorporating these psychological principles into your content strategy and watch your audience respond in meaningful ways.

For more insights and resources on marketing strategies, visit thestephaniescheller.com and take your marketing to the next level.